top of page

REVIEW: The Dutch House by Anna Patchet

Oct 2, 2020
2 min read

Updated: Sep 29

Here's what the book is about: A rich father buys an old property, the mother hates the house, so she abandons her family and disappears. Why? For what reason? The father remarries a much younger woman and dies soon after. The two kids, now in college, live with their stepmother until she throws them out, since the house is legally hers. Yet, something keeps on bringing the siblings back to the lure of the house.


I was really intrigued by this book but it turned out to be a huge disappointment for me. The first chapter held my interest, but starting from the second, I felt disconnected from everything happening in the novel. There's an interesting dynamic between Danny and Maeve, the way brother and sister develop a deeply codependent relationship, meeting once a month just to sit in a car and watch the house from outside. There's something genuinely tragic about losing your childhood home: not just the physical place, but the memories attached to it, and the idea you'd built of your own youth around it.


I read it as a modern Hansel and Gretel story, and the book leans into that comparison directly, which makes sense given that Danny and Maeve are essentially two siblings lost in a concrete jungle. There's even a Cinderella element in Andrea, the evil stepmother, except she's given no light and shade at all, no context for why she's so cartoonishly cruel. She's placed in direct contrast to Danny and Maeve's largely absent birth mother, who, despite effectively abandoning her children, is repeatedly excused by the narrative because she's framed as "good" and "saintly," off doing worthwhile charity work in India. Leaning on such starkly opposite archetypes felt like lazy shorthand for character development on both ends: one woman is cruel because the book needs a villain, the other is forgiven because the book needs a saint, and neither reads like an actual person. Everyone gets their reckoning, in one way or another, but the birth mother remained, by far, the most underdeveloped character in the book. The idea behind her isn't bad; this could have been a genuinely strong character study. Instead, it just felt flat.


The house is probably meant as a metaphor for a painful past that's difficult to move past, or a symbol of childhood trauma that lingers into adulthood and shapes the future, which fits the siblings raised in the Dutch House well enough in theory. Ann Patchett herself has said the house is "just symbolic of life," which actually explains why it never became something more interesting.


I know plenty of readers find this story engaging, and my opinion is probably the minority one, but I have to be honest: this was a boring, unemotional read for me. Trying to find something positive to say, the atmosphere was intriguing, it was short and the cover is genuinely beautiful.


2/5 ✰

Comments


bottom of page